嗔秤戻幣�哉膵�云利匈嬉蝕湊蛸賜�塋床四衲���萩晦編報炎嘔囚^泡仟 ̄云利匈�《超噌�殻窟�嵌虜隆輓麈觚翹瀘卉韮�仍仍�。� 烏御危列
伊嵐弌傍利 卦指云慕朕村 厘議慕尺 厘議慕禰 TXT畠云和墮 序秘慕杏 紗秘慕禰

my name is red-厘議兆忖出碕-及64何蛍

梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ○ 賜 ★ 辛酔堀貧和鍬匈��梓囚徒貧議 Enter 囚辛指欺云慕朕村匈��梓囚徒貧圭�鮗� ● 辛指欺云匈競何��
!!!!隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��



picture of a horse�拭院�
^I once saw a winged horse in an enchanting book that a great teacher�察�a 
scholar of scholars�察�had presented to my late hoja。 ̄ 
I didn¨t know whether I should push the head of this clown into his soup�察�
who�察�along with his teacher�察�had taken Strange Creatures seriously�察�and drown 
him or leave him to describe in glowing terms the only horse picture he¨d ever 
seen in his life!in who knows how poor a manuscript copy。 I came up with a 
third  alternative�察 �and  that  was  to  drop  my  spoon  and  quit  the  shop。  After 
walking for a long while I entered the abandoned dervish lodge�察�where I was 
overe with a sense of peace。 I tidied up and without doing anything else�察�I 
listened to the silence。 
307 
 
Later�察�I removed the mirror from where I kept it hidden and set it upon the 
low worktable。 Next�察�I placed the two´page illustration and the drawing board 
on  my  lap。  When  I  could  see  my  face  in  the  mirror  from  where  I  sat�察 �I 
attempted to draw my portrait in charcoal。 I drew for a long time�察�patiently。 
Much later�察�when I saw that once again the face on the page didn¨t resemble 
my  face  in  the  mirror�察 �I  was  filled  with  such  misery  that  tears  welled  in  my 
eyes。 How did the Veian painters that Enishte described with such flourish 
do it�拭�I then imagined myself to be one of them�察�thinking that if I illustrated in 
that state of mind�察�I could perhaps make a convincing self´portrait。 
Later still�察�I cursed the European painters and Enishte both�察�erased what I¨d 
done and began looking into the mirror anew to begin another drawing。 
Ultimately�察 �I  found  myself  wandering  the  streets  again�察 �and  then�察 �here�察 �at 
this despicable coffeehouse。 I wasn¨t even sure how I happened to e here。 
As I entered�察�I felt such embarrassment about mingling with these miserable 
miniaturists and calligraphers that sweat accumulated on my forehead。 
I  sensed  that  they  were  watching  me�察 �alerting  each  other  of  my  presence 
with their elbows�察�and laughing!all right�察�I could plainly see them doing it。 I 
seated myself in the corner�察�trying to behave naturally。 At the same time my 
eyes sought the other masters�察�my dear brethren with whom�察�at one time�察�I¨d 
served  as  Master  Osman¨s  apprentice。  I  was  certain  each  of  them  was  also 
asked  to  draw  a  horse  this  evening  and  that  they¨d  each  expended  great 
desperate efforts�察�taking the contest arranged by these idiots quite seriously。 
The  storyteller  effendi  hadn¨t  yet  begun  his  performance。  The  picture 
hadn¨t even been hung up yet。 I was forced to socialize with the coffeehouse 
crowd。 
So  be  it  then�察 �let  me  be  frank  with  you�此 �Like  everyone  else  I�察 �too�察 �made 
jokes�察 �told  indecent  stories�察 �kissed  my  panions  on  the  cheeks  with 
exaggerated  gestures�察 �spoke  in  double  entendres�察 �innuendos  and  puns�察 �asked 
how  the  young  assistant  masters  were  doing�察 �and  like  everybody  else�察�
mercilessly needled our mon enemies�察�and after I really warmed up�察�I went 
so far as to roughhouse and kiss men on the neck。 Yet�察�knowing that a part of 
my  soul  remained  mercilessly  silent  when  I  involved  myself  in  such  behavior 
caused me unbearable torment。 
Noheless�察�before long�察�I not only succeeded in using figurative language 
to pare my own cock�察�and those of others that were much´talked about�察�to 
brushes�察 �reeds�察 �coffeehouse  pillars�察 �flutes�察 �newel  posts�察 �door  knockers�察 �leeks�察�
minarets�察�lady fingers in heavy syrup�察�pine trees�察�and twice�察�to the world itself�察�
308 
 
I was equally successful in paring the asses of much´discussed pretty boys 
to  oranges�察 �figs�察 �small  haycocklike  pastries�察 �pillows  and  also  to  tiny  anthills。 
Meanwhile�察 �the  most  conceited  of  the  calligraphers  my  age  was  only  able  to 
pare his oateurishly and without any self´confidence I 
might  add!to  a  ship¨s  mast  and  a  porter¨s  pole。  Furthermore�察 �I  made 
allusions  to  old  miniaturists¨  dicks  that  would  no  longer  rise�察 �the  cherry´
colored  lips  of  new  apprentices�察 �master  calligraphers  who  hoarded  their 
money ��as did I�� in a certain place �─�the most disgusting nook ̄���察�how perhaps 
opium had been put into the wine I was drinking instead of rose petals�察�the 
last  great  masters  of  Tabriz  and  Shiraz�察 �the  mixing  of  coffee  and  wine  in 
Aleppo�察�and the calligraphers and beautiful boys to be found there。 
At times it seemed that one of the two spirits within me had�察�in the end�察�
emerged  victorious�察 �leaving  the  other  behind�察 �and  that  I¨d  finally  forgotten 
that  silent  and  loveless  aspect  of  myself。  At  these  times  I  remembered  the 
holiday  celebrations  of  my  childhood  during  which  I  was  able  to  be  myself 
along with my kith and kin。 Despite all these jokes�察�kisses and embraces�察�there 
was still a silence within me that left me suffering and isolated in the heart of 
the crowd。 
Who  had  endowed  me  with  this  silent  and  merciless  spirit!it  was  not  a 
spirit but a jinn!which always chided me and cut me off from others�拭�Satan�拭�
But  the  silence  within  me  was  eased�察 �not  by  the  crass  mischief  instigated  by 
Satan�察 �on  the  contrary�察 �by  the  most  pure  and  simple  stories  that  drove  into 
one¨s  soul。  Under  the  influence  of  wine�察 �I  told  two  stories�察 �hoping  that  this 
would  grant  me  peace。  A  tall�察 �pale�察 �yet  pinkish´plected  calligrapher¨s 
apprentice focused his green eyes onto mine and was listening to me with rapt 
attention。 
 
Two Stories on Blindness and Style 
the Miniaturist Told to Ease the Loneliness in His Soul 
 
ALIF 
Contrary to what is assumed�察�making drawings of horses by looking at actual 
horses wasn¨t a discovery of European masters。 The original idea belonged to 
the  great  master  Jemalettin  of  Kazvin。  After  Tall  Hasan�察 �the  Khan  of  the 
Whitesheep�察�conquered Kazvin�察�the old master Jemalettin was not content to 
simply join the book´arts workshop of the victorious khan�察�instead he headed 
out on campaign with him�察�claiming that he wanted to embellish the khan¨s 
309 
 
History with scenes of war he¨d witnessed himself。 So this great master�察�who 
for  sixty´two  years  had  made  pictures  of  horses�察 �cavalry  charges  and  battles 
without ever having seen a battle�察�went to war for the first time。 But before he 
could even see the thunderous and violent clash of sweating horses�察�he lost his 
hands and his eyesight to enemy cannon´fire。 The old master�察�like all genuine 
virtuosos�察 �had  in  any  case  been  awaiting  blindness  as  though  it  were  Allah¨s 
blessing�察�and neither did he treat the loss of his hands as a great deficiency。 He 
maintained that the memory of a miniaturist was located not in the hand�察�as 
some insisted�察�but in the intellect and the heart�察�and furthermore�察�now that he 
was blind�察�he declared that he could see the true pictures�察�scenery and essential 
and  flawless  horses  that  Allah  manded  be  seen。  To  share  these  wonders 
with  lovers  of  art�察 �he  hired  a  tall�察 �pale´skinned�察 �pink´plected�察 �green´eyed 
calligrapher¨s  apprentice  to  whom  he  dictated  exactly  how  to  draw  the 
marvelous  horses  that  appeared  to  him  in  God¨s  divine  darkness!as  he 
would¨ve drawn them had he been able to hold a brush in his hands。 After the 
master¨s death�察�his account of how to draw 303 horses beginning from the left 
foreleg  was  collected  by  the  handsome  calligrapher¨s  apprentice  into  three 
volumes respectively entitled The Depiction of Horses�察�The Flow of Horses and The 
Love of Horses�察�which were quite widely liked and sought after for a time in the 
regions where the Whitesheep ruled。 Though they appeared in a variety of new 
editions  and  copies�察 �were  memorized  by  illustrators�察 �apprentices  and  their 
students  and  were  used  as  practice  books�察 �after  Tall  Hasan¨s  Whitesheep 
nation was obliterated and the Herat style of illustration overtook all of Persia�察�
Jemalettin  and  his  manuscripts  were  forgotten。  Doubtless�察 �the  logic  behind 
Kemalettin R��za of Herat¨s violent criticism of these three volumes in his book 
The Blindman¨s Horses�察�and his conclusion that they ought to be burned�察�had 
figured in this turn of events。 Kemalettin R��za claimed that none of the horses 
described  by  Jemalettin  of  Kazvin  in  his  three  volumes  could  be  a  horse  of 
God¨s vision!because none of them were ^immaculate�察院�since the old master 
had  described  them  after  he¨d  witnessed  an  actual  battle  scene�察 �no  matter 
how  briefly。  Since  the  treasures  of  Tall  Hasan  of  the  Whitesheep  had  been 
plundered  by  Sultan  Mehmet  the  Conqueror  and  brought  to  Istanbul�察 �it 
should  e  as  no  surprise  that  occasionally  certain  of  these  303  stories 
appear in other manuscripts in Istanbul and even that some horses are drawn 
as instructed therein。 
 
   
310 
 
LAM 
In  Herat  and  Shiraz�察 �when  a  master  miniaturist  nearing  the  end  of  his  days 
went blind from a lifetime of excessive labor�察�it would not only be taken as a 
sign  of  that  master¨s  determination�察 �but  would  be  mended  as  God¨s 
acknowledgment of the great master¨s work and talent。 There was even a time 
in Herat when masters who hadn¨t gone blind despite having grown old were 
regarded  with  suspicion�察 �a  situation  that  pelled  quite  a  few  of  them  to 
actually  induce  blindness  in  their  old  age。  There  was  a  long  period  during 
which men reverently recalled artists who blinded themselves�察�following in the 
path of those legendary masters who¨d done so rather than work for another 
monarch  or  change  their  styles。  And  it  was  during  this  age  that  Abu  Said�察�
Tamerlane¨s  grandson  from  the  Miran  Shah  line  of  descent�察 �introduced  a 
further twist in his workshop after he¨d conquered Tashkent and Samarkand�此�
The  practice  of  paying  greater  homage  to  the  imitation  of  blindness  than  to 
blindness  itself。  Black  Veli�察 �the  old  artisan  who  inspired  Abu  Said�察 �had 
confirmed that a blind miniaturist could see the horses of God¨s vision from 
within the darkness�察�however�察�true talent resided in a sighted miniaturist who 
could regard the world like a blind man。 At the age of sixty´seven he proved his 
point  by  dashing  off  a  horse  that  came  to  the  tip  of  his  brush  without  so 
much  as  a  glance  at  the  paper�察 �even  as  his  eyes  remained  all  the  while  open 
and  fixed  on  the  page。  At  the  end  of  this  artistic  ceremony  for  which  Miran 
Shah  had  deaf  musicians  play  lutes  and  mute  storytellers  recite  stories  to 
support the legendary master¨s efforts�察�the splendid horse that Black Veli had 
drawn  was  pared  at  length  with  other  horses  he¨d  made�此 �There  was  no 
difference   whatsoever   among   them�察  �much   to   Miran   Shah¨s   irritation�察�
thereafter�察 �the  legendary  master  declared  that  a  miniaturist  possessed  of 
talent�察�regardless of whether his eyes are open or closed�察�will always and only 
see horses in one way�察�that is�察�the way that Allah perceives them。 And among 
great  master  miniaturists�察 �there  is  no  difference  between  the  blind  and  the 
sighted�此�The hand would always draw the same horse because there was as yet 
no  such  thing  as  the  Frankish  innovation  called  ^style。 ̄  The  horses  made  by 
the great master Black Veli have been imitated by all Muslim miniaturists for 
110  years。  As  for  Black  Veli  himself�察 �after  the  defeat  of  Abu  Said  and  the 
dispersal  of  his  workshop�察 �he  moved  from  Samarkand  to  Kazvin�察 �where  two 
years later he was condemned for his spiteful attempts to refute the verse in 
the Glorious Koran that declares�察 �The blind and the seeing are not equal。 ̄ For 
this�察�he was first blinded�察�then killed by young Nizam Shah¨s soldiers。 
 
311 
 
I  was  on  the  verge  of  telling  a  third  story�察 �describing  to  the  pretty´eyed 
calligrapher¨s  apprentice  how  the  great  master  Bihzad  had  blinded  himself�察�
卦指朕村 貧匯匈 和匯匈 指欺競何 壘��2�� 家��2��
隆堋響頼��紗秘慕禰厮宴和肝写偬堋響��
梁椣戻幣�� 梁心弌傍議揖扮窟燕得胎��傍竃徭失議心隈才凪万弌誌育断蛍�輌臆惨軼僑〃�燕慕得珊辛參資誼持蛍才将刮襲潜��範寔亟圻幹慕得 瓜寡追葎娼得辛參資誼寄楚署衛、持蛍才将刮襲潜填��